Federal Court Is a Soap Opera With Footnotes

You know what never lies?
A calendar.

Federal court cases love two things: dates and who had authority on those dates. So here’s your Superior PD Promotion & Retirement Decoder Ring—built for anyone tired of “We take this seriously” while your tax bill quietly weeps.

A Superior, Wisconsin tax graphic shows a $200,000 home generating about $1,000 to the city, with city hall, roads, police, parks and library.

How to Use This Ring

When a complaint says any of this, grab the timeline:

    • “Supervisor / Sergeant / Captain / Chief” = who held rank that day

    • “Policy-maker” = who owned the rulebook

    • “Failure to train / supervise” = who ran the machine

    • “Retaliation / hostile work environment” = who controlled the workplace heat

Match the incident date to the command date. That’s the trick, and remember Mayor Jim Paine in charge through it all.

The Crown Swap That Matters

    • End of Jan. 2024: Nicholas Alexander retires as Chief.

    • Jan. 27 / Jan. 29, 2024: Paul Winterscheidt sworn in as Chief. 

Translation: before Feb. 2024 = Alexander era.
After Feb. 2024 = Winterscheidt era.
Lawyers love eras. So do Federal juries.

The Timeline (2020–June 4, 2026)

    • Jan. 3 / Jan. 8, 2020: Bethany Kemi + Michael/Mitch Pitoscia sworn in.

    • Jan. 8, 2020: Retirements noted: Officer Maas, Officer Beste, Officer Hanson; Assistant Chief Markon set to retire in April.

    • Feb. 12, 2020: Probation completion: Ashley Johnson.

    • Mar. 11, 2020: Police Officer certified hire list approved.

    • June 11, 2020: John Kiel replaces retiring Matt Markon as Assistant Chief; Sgt. Jack Curphy retires; Sgt. Chris Kirchoff has upcoming retirement.

    • Sept. 9, 2020: Promotions paperwork received for Kiel, Winterscheidt, Eastman, Harriman, Letendre.

    • Aug. 31, 2020: Sgt. Jon McKinnon retires (effective).
See also  FOIA City - City Attorney Suggests Delaying Response

    • Oct. 5, 2020: Sgt. Chris Kirchoff retires (effective).

    • Sept. 9, 2020: Probation completions: Finkbeiner, Pope.

    • Oct. 14, 2020: Promotions paperwork received for Joel Markon, Christopher Woolery, Matthew Brown.

    • Oct. 14, 2020: Probation completions: Matthew Swanson, Austin Lauridsen.

    • Dec. 21, 2020 (planned; referenced Dec. 9 minutes): Swearing-in planned for Brittany Letica, Hillary Peterson, Lauren Phillips.

Decoder note: churn creates gaps. Gaps create more lawsuits.

A vintage milk carton parody reads MISSING and Superior's Human Resources Department, with notes about employee complaints and ignored grievances.

2021: More Boots, Same Gravity

    • May 21, 2021: Four unnamed officers sworn in.

Decoder note: more hiring means more training questions.

2022: Staffing Shortage Joins the Cast

    • Aug. 1, 2022: SPD reported down seven sworn officers; city sought applicants; hiring list activity discussed.

Decoder note: “understaffed” becomes the all-purpose excuse flavor.

2023: Probations, a Resignation, and the Chief Exit Trailer

    • Jan. 11, 2023 / Mar. 9, 2023: Probation completions listed/approved: Greg Mertzig, Collin Deans-Brandt, Taylor Wendt, Jarid Rankila.

    • Mar. 15, 2023: Seth Noll resignation effective.

    • June 14, 2023: Probation completion listed: Mundell.

    • Oct. 9, 2023: Alexander announces retirement effective end of Jan. 2024.

    • Dec. 1, 2023: Winterscheidt announced as next Chief.

Decoder note: transition periods breed “I don’t recall” like it’s spring pollen.

2024: New Chief, New Promotions, Same Taxpayers

    • Jan. 12, 2024: Retirement party for Alexander.

    • Jan. 26–29, 2024: Leadership transition; Winterscheidt sworn in as Chief.

    • Feb. 26, 2024: William Lear promoted to Patrol Captain.

    • Mar. 11, 2024: Sean Holmgren promoted to ICAC Sergeant.

    • Apr. 6, 2024: Tyler Rude promoted to Patrol Sergeant.

    • July 10, 2024: Probation completions listed: Jago, Lofgren, Crist.
See also  Outrage Over Former Officer's Drunken Hit-and-Run: A Deep Dive into Justice System Failures

    • Sept. 5, 2024: Probationary officer Justin Taylor resigns (effective).

    • Nov. 11, 2024: Zachary Pfisthner resigns (effective).

    • Dec. 1, 2024: Probationary officer Jason Moen resigns (effective).

Decoder note: captains sign things. Sergeants supervise things. Paperwork remembers.

Infographic titled City Hall Budget Overruns showing department spending bars such as Police Department and Administration & Engineering with dollar values in red and gold

2025: Movement, Probations, and a Headline-Ready Exit

    • Apr. 29, 2025: Abigail Bartlett resigns (effective).

    • May 22, 2025: Louis Aguinaga completes probation.

    • Aug. 13, 2025: Probation completions noted: Ben Olson, Captain Jeff Harriman, Sergeant Sean Holmgren, Sergeant Tyler Rude.

    • Sept. 29, 2025: Investigator Mikayla LeRette resigns (effective).

    • Oct. 7, 2025: Andrew Elmquist + Ibrahim Carson complete probation (effective).

    • Dec. 18, 2025: Peter Heehn completes probation (effective).

Decoder note: resignation dates love to show up in discovery.

Colorful neon light trails and musical notes swirl around a black police vehicle labeled “POLICE” and “CITY OF SUPERIOR” as a driver DJ-controls audio gear the remix.

2026 (Through June 4): Promotions, K-9 Retirement, Hiring List

    • Jan. 5, 2026: Thor Trone promoted to Patrol Captain.

    • Jan. 13, 2026: Russ Milroy promoted to Investigations Captain.

    • Jan. 14, 2026: Record references probation completion for Peter Heehn (completed Dec. 18, 2025).

    • Feb. 26, 2026: K-9 Radik retires; handler noted: Sgt. Tyler Rude.

    • Apr. 8, 2026: Police Officer Hiring List approved.

Decoder note: new captains = new command chain. New chain = new liability map.

Final Crossing Signal

This ring doesn’t prove wrongdoing. It does something better.
It shows who held rank when decisions happened. That’s what federal court cares about. 

And taxpayers should care too—because when “accountability” shows up late, it arrives with attorney fees.

See also  Superior Outsources Transparency—And Possibly Your Internet History—to a Florida Startup
A federal court filing stack marked Filed sits beside the U.S. District Court seal and gavel, tied to Mikayla Marie LeRette v. City of Superior.

FEDERAL COURT – Brady Status Email – LeRette Case

June 6, 2026 No Comments

This FOIA record contains a May 16, 2025 email from Kate Harrell to Mikayla LeRette, Robert Powell, and Richard Gondik. The subject is “Re: Brady Consideration.” The email discusses whether Douglas County District Attorney Mark Fruehauf had made a Brady or Giglio determination about LeRette. The thread follows LeRette’s May 15, 2025 message. She asked for clarity about what the district attorney needed before clearing

Read More »
A gritty Port Washington and Ozaukee County collage shows a decoder ring, calendar notes, police files, and clues about leadership swaps and settlements.

SPD Decoder Ring: Leadership Swaps That Lawyers Love

June 5, 2026 No Comments

Federal Court Is a Soap Opera With Footnotes You know what never lies?A calendar. Federal court cases love two things: dates and who had authority on those dates. So here’s your Superior PD Promotion & Retirement Decoder Ring—built for anyone tired of “We take this seriously” while your tax bill quietly weeps. How to Use This Ring When a complaint says any of this, grab the

Read More »
A federal court filing stack marked Filed sits beside the U.S. District Court seal and gavel, tied to Mikayla Marie LeRette v. City of Superior.

FEDERAL COURT : LeRette Duty Return – DA Fruehauf Warning

June 4, 2026 No Comments

Email Shows Officer LeRette Returned To Duty This email thread dates from November 18–19, 2024. It centers on Officer LeRette’s return from administrative leave. Douglas County District Attorney Mark Fruehauf asked City of Superior officials for an update on the internal process involving LeRette. He wrote that he had heard she was restored to active duty. He also stated his understanding that the internal process

Read More »

Related posts:

Voting for Accountability: Why Superior Can't Afford The Van Sickle & Elm Show Again

Superior Wisconsin's Landfill Crisis: Overlooked Alerts and Rising Costs for Residents

Legal Bills - Legal Invoice for NTEC Battle (February 2024)

You May Also Like

A man wearing glasses and a patterned suit with money floating around him in the air.
on

Is Mayor Jim Paine’s Leadership Hurting Superior, WI? Another Federal Lawsuit Creates More Controversy!

Bold SoupNutz banner presents federal court documents, a courthouse facade, and a filed exhibit tied to Lucas Ciciora and Mayor Paine in Superior.
on

FEDERAL COURT – Superior’s 50k OIR Report Clears Pope in LeRette Claims ?

Memorial Day legal sunburn artwork shows Superior, Wisconsin City Hall, Mayor Jim Paine, and LeRette court filings amid federal complaints and records stacks.
on

This Memorial Day City Hall Gets a Legal Sunburn