Mayor Jim Paine Post August 19th 2024
Mayor Paine’s Reckless Spending and Council’s Blind Loyalty Are Crushing Superior Taxpayers
Superior taxpayers are being pushed to the financial brink. Property tax bills are surging anywhere from 10% to 90% following skyrocketing reassessments, yet Mayor Jim Paine continues to expand city spending with little regard for the financial burden placed on residents. Worse still, a core group of city councilors — Lindsey Graskey, Ruth Ludwig, Garner Moffat, Nicholas Ledin, Tylor Elm, and the mayor’s wife, Councilor Jenny Van Sickle — have enabled this mess through their unwavering support of the mayor’s fiscal decisions.
Families Struggle as Spending Grows
Homeowners across Superior are now staring down shocking property tax hikes, with increases ranging from 10% to 90%. These sharp jumps come after reassessments pushed property values up an average of 60% citywide. For families already struggling with rising costs of living, these tax hikes are not just painful — they’re unsustainable.
Rather than offer relief or show fiscal restraint, Mayor Paine’s 2025 budget inflates city spending to $35.9 million. To make matters worse, the mayor is pushing for $10 million in new debt for vague “potential projects” without offering residents any clear plan or accountability.
Yet Mayor Paine’s reckless fiscal behavior doesn’t stop there. His own unpaid city utility bills wound up on his property taxes a glaring sign of carelessness that raises serious questions about his ability to manage the city’s finances responsibly.
Council Enables the Mayor’s Financial Mess
While residents struggle with rising taxes and growing frustration, Mayor Paine has found unwavering allies on the city council. City Councilors Lindsey Graskey, Ruth Ludwig, Garner Moffat, Nicholas Ledin, Tylor Elm, and Jenny Van Sickle — the mayor’s own wife — have rubber-stamped his spending priorities and borrowing proposals without holding him accountable for their consequences.
Their loyalty to the mayor comes at the direct expense of Superior taxpayers. Instead of standing up for residents being crushed by 10% to 90% tax hikes, this group has repeatedly chosen to support budgets and policies that increase spending and push the city further into debt.
Taxpayers Deserve Accountability
Superior families deserve leadership that prioritizes their needs, not leadership that expands government spending while ignoring the very real struggles of taxpayers. Mayor Paine’s financial missteps — combined with the blind support of councilors Graskey, Ludwig, Moffat, Ledin, Elm, and Van Sickle — have created a financial mess that homeowners now have to clean up.
It’s time for real accountability. City leaders must rein in spending, reject unnecessary borrowing, and make taxpayers their top priority.
Mayor and Councilors Property Taxes
Mayor Paine 2024 Taxes & 2023 Taxes : $293.29 or 14.91% Increase
Tylor Elms 2024 Taxes & 2023 Taxes : $725.45 or 44.27% Increase
Garner Moffat 2024 Taxes & 2023 Taxes : $991.99 or 88.59% Increase
Nicholas Ledin 2024 Taxes & 2023 Taxes : $252.53 or 14.03% Increase
Lindsey Graskey No Property Tax Records Located
Jenny Van Sickle No Property Tax Records Located
Ruth Ludwig No Property Tax Records Located
Sourced : Douglas County Web Portal
Sources
Sheriff Matthew Izzard & Chairman Mark Liebart: Is Accountability on Backorder in Douglas County?
Money Flows Like Lake Superior… Just Not Toward Accountability Douglas County has discovered a magical power. They can find money. Money for studies.Money for facilities.Money for upgrades.Money for “strategic initiatives.” But somehow — when the topic turns to dash cams and body cams for the Sheriff’s Department — the vault slams shut like Fort Knox on a diet. And here’s the question voters are starting to whisper
FOIA DOCS – Ian Cuypers v. Superior Police Department Officers and City of Superior – Federal Civil Rights Complaint (October 24, 2024)
This federal civil rights complaint was filed on October 24, 2024, in the United States District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin by Plaintiff Ian Cuypers against officers of the Superior Police Department and the City of Superior. The lawsuit arises from a February 24, 2024 traffic stop in Superior, Wisconsin, during which Cuypers alleges officers used excessive force against him. According to the
2019 RW Report Told Us the Dump Was Dying—So Why Act Shocked in 2026 ?
Superior’s landfill is nearing closure, yet decisions are stalled. Delaying costs more—residents deserve transparency and timely planning.
FOIA DOCS – Superior Police Chief Meets Reporter on Feb. 28 Traffic Stop (March 2024)
This document is a two-page email exchange dated March 29, 2024, filed as Exhibit 27-9 in Cuypers v. Taylor et al., Case No. 3:24-cv-00743. The correspondence documents communication between Paul Winterscheidt, Chief of Police for the City of Superior, and Maria Lockwood, a reporter with the Superior Telegram, regarding a police traffic stop that occurred on February 28, 2024. The exchange begins with Reporter Maria
FOIA DOC – Superior Police Chief Explains Taser Use to City Council (April 2024)
This document is a three-page email chain dated April 3–5, 2024, later filed as Exhibit 27-10 in Cuypers v. Taylor et al., Case No. 3:24-cv-00743. The correspondence centers on public concerns raised about a Superior Police Department traffic stop that resulted in the use of a conducted energy weapon (Taser) and a resisting charge against Ian Richard Cuypers. The email exchange involves Tylor Elm, a
