Union Love Lost: Why Mayor Jim’s Hand-Picked Crew Can’t Score a Hard-Hat Hug

❌ What the Letters Actually Say

The gas plant risks “serious harm to health, safety, economy, and cultural heritage.” – Jim Paine, in his official NTEC objection letter

The project “only creates risks for the community without benefits to offset the risks.” – Councilor Garner Moffat

“Even though NTEC may decrease overall CO₂ in MISO, the city would see an increase in CO₂ emissions.” – Councilor Nick Ledin

Three letters, all Mayor Jims chorus: Gas bad, jobs meh. Way to support your district.

Mayor Jim Paine puppets with two bearded dummies wearing brown pants and plaid blue shirt, one with a collar tag and the other holding a wooden gavel, in an indoor office-like room with blue curtains

 


Why Unions Rolled Their Eyes

1. 350 Union Paychecks Vaporized

NTEC’s build phase meant about 350 union construction jobs. You trash the plant, you torched peoples wages.

2. Copy-Paste Messaging

The mayor pens a doom scroll, his favorites echo it word-for-word. Hard hats can smell an orchestrated talking point the way a welder smells burnt insulation.

3. Contrast Candidate Records

CandidateStance on NTECTrades Council Endorsement
Brent FennesseyVoted “Let’s build and get to work.”Yes
Weston MorrisPublicly backed the project.Yes
Nick LedinSigned the anti-jobs letter.No
Garner MoffatDitto.No

When labor asked, “Who’s guarding our paychecks?” the mayor’s crew pointed at a PowerPoint about carbon.


Parody newspaper front page showing Mayor Jim Paine and city officials at a podium, bold red headline 'MAYOR'S CREW GETS UNION BOOT!' with workers in hard hats in the foreground

The Political Math

Hard-hat endorsement = volunteers + yard signs + checks.
Anti-plant letter = viral kudos from College Professors.
Election Day reward system? Still strictly cash and shoe-leather.


SoupNutz Mic-Drop

Mayor Jim’s voting bloc  chose a megaphone over a toolbox. The unions chose people who bring lunch pails, not speeches. Funny how that works.

Page 26 for Quotes

app-f-summary-rsea-comments-12142023