This email chain from August 21, 2022 through September 6, 2022 documents coordination between the City of Superior, the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (DNR), and the Paine family regarding a conservation easement on waterfront property in Superior, Wisconsin. City Councilor Jenny Van Sickle “Paine” reached out to DNR Lake Superior Supervisor Cherie Hagen to help clarify the status and boundaries of an easement linked historically to the Barker’s Island Bird Sanctuary. Hagen requested background materials so DNR real estate staff could advise on next steps, including a copy of the easement, property description, ownership history, and a summary of the City’s concerns.

By September 6, 2022, City Economic Development, Planning & Port Director Jason Serck provided DNR with a limited development easement recorded in March 1989, maps, and ownership information for Section 16, Township 49 North, Range 14 West. The emails also show input from Thomas Paine, who indicates his family did not receive notice that the bird sanctuary area had shifted onto their land and that they are seeking clarity on any land trade or sale involving the City. A meeting to resolve the issue was being considered for late September 2022.